Hood vs. Scharnhorst
Hood vs. Scharnhorst
Just for giggles…hypothetical match up between Hood and Scharnhorst. Who has the edge and why?
My vote is with Hood.
My vote is with Hood.
In 1940-41 the Scharnhorst is 1-2 knots faster than Hood, armor is more or less similar in both ships, but in my opinion Hood has the edge because she has bigger guns. I'm not sure if the 11-inch gun has power enough to penetrate to Hood magazines like Bismarck did, but the 15-inch from Hood can do a lot of damage to Scharnhorst. I remember the battle of North Cape where the unfortunate hit of a 14-inch shell from Duke of York destroyed a Scharnhorst boiler room .
-
- Junior Member
- Posts: 4
- Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 2:35 am
- Location: Singapore
Hood's fire director system was particularly obsolete. The caliber of the gun is not the only question when confronting both artillery platforms.
The accuracy of the german battlecruisers was quite well proven during the long range shooting that crippled the Glorius. The Hood ability to obtain any hit would decrease dramatically after the first impacts received becouse the british did not protect particularly well their fire control system. With Hood would result far more efficient HE bombardment from long distance in order to disable the poor fire control station, while the chance to receive a hit from Hood from Hood would result quite small.
After the Hood would be forced to shift to local control, local fire the Scharharnorst could remain far from the victim, the best protection of the Germans warships being the obsolescence of the fire control system.
The accuracy of the german battlecruisers was quite well proven during the long range shooting that crippled the Glorius. The Hood ability to obtain any hit would decrease dramatically after the first impacts received becouse the british did not protect particularly well their fire control system. With Hood would result far more efficient HE bombardment from long distance in order to disable the poor fire control station, while the chance to receive a hit from Hood from Hood would result quite small.
After the Hood would be forced to shift to local control, local fire the Scharharnorst could remain far from the victim, the best protection of the Germans warships being the obsolescence of the fire control system.
I agree with Attlante, during the Denmarck Strait battle Hood never took his main aim (Prinz Eugen) despite of the many salvos shooted with his A and B towers.
May be in a long range fight Scharnorst fire precision would have been made the difference.
But who knows, lucky is blind...
May be in a long range fight Scharnorst fire precision would have been made the difference.
But who knows, lucky is blind...
"Wir kämpfen bis zur letzten Granate."
Günther Lütjens
Günther Lütjens
- Karl Heidenreich
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4808
- Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2006 3:19 pm
- Location: San José, Costa Rica
Gary:
Agree, Schanhorst 11" are not a match for Hood´s 15". The speed will help only to run away.In 1940-41 the Scharnhorst is 1-2 knots faster than Hood,
Hood was only good for about 29 knots by that Time.
Scharnhorst could hit 32 knots.
This battle would in all probabilty be a British victory
An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last.
Sir Winston Churchill
Sir Winston Churchill
Karl Heidenreich wrote:Gary:Agree, Schanhorst 11" are not a match for Hood´s 15". The speed will help only to run away.In 1940-41 the Scharnhorst is 1-2 knots faster than Hood,
Hood was only good for about 29 knots by that Time.
Scharnhorst could hit 32 knots.
This battle would in all probabilty be a British victory
What if Scharnhorst had six 15 inch guns?
- Terje Langoy
- Supporter
- Posts: 435
- Joined: Wed Aug 09, 2006 4:15 pm
- Location: Bergen, Norway
Wouldn't the outcome of the battle be dependent of a whole lot more than just gun size..? I mean factors like: Who spots who first and at what range? Bearing and speed of each ship? Course of action made by each of the commanders? (although I think the Hood would have pursued any possibility as the Scharnhorst would not) And how about weather and sea conditions? Time of day?
I think they would have made a status quo in a stern chase and thus make it a matter of endurance or luck. If the Scarnhorst had 15-inches, I guess she would not tuck tail and run but then again it would be a question of who's landing the first heavy hit. That's how I see it...
Regards
I think they would have made a status quo in a stern chase and thus make it a matter of endurance or luck. If the Scarnhorst had 15-inches, I guess she would not tuck tail and run but then again it would be a question of who's landing the first heavy hit. That's how I see it...
Regards
hey....
if we include decisions taken by commanders, etc...
then we could never assess a battle between two ships...
because we can never really predict wat a commander would hav done at wat moment, etc
one thing is the weather....
both ships were very WET ships...
still i think the Scharnhorst would be worse affected....
and even with 15in guns....i must say the odds are still on for the Hood...
although i LOVE the scharnhorst...
miro
if we include decisions taken by commanders, etc...
then we could never assess a battle between two ships...
because we can never really predict wat a commander would hav done at wat moment, etc
one thing is the weather....
both ships were very WET ships...
still i think the Scharnhorst would be worse affected....
and even with 15in guns....i must say the odds are still on for the Hood...
although i LOVE the scharnhorst...
miro
Die See ruft....
- Terje Langoy
- Supporter
- Posts: 435
- Joined: Wed Aug 09, 2006 4:15 pm
- Location: Bergen, Norway
Hello...
First of all, you're completely right concerning the commanders...
But, the 11-inches of the Scharnhorst should be able to penetrate the armour of the Hood at some range, right? They weren't just toy guns!
How about rate of fire, accuracy and range between the BC's? Doesn't this also matter a lot?
If the Hood can exploit her bigger guns at great range I'd favour her, but in a close-up...
Regards
First of all, you're completely right concerning the commanders...
But, the 11-inches of the Scharnhorst should be able to penetrate the armour of the Hood at some range, right? They weren't just toy guns!
How about rate of fire, accuracy and range between the BC's? Doesn't this also matter a lot?
If the Hood can exploit her bigger guns at great range I'd favour her, but in a close-up...
Regards