Naval History Forums

Ciao all, just few addittional things from my side : to Randy : 1) No matter which speed you choose for Bismarck the initial first salvo photo of Bismarck that shows her between 1800 and 2500 meters back on Prinz Eugen wake ( we will see later the correct estimation ) clearly makes impossible Mr. Wi...

Ciao George and all,

I have several e-mails.

Anyway, here is my personal official one :

Antonio_Bonomi@Virgilio.it

and it is always attached on the closure of all my post on all forum's were I write, no problems, you can write me there.

Ciao Antonio

Ciao George, Randy, Ian, Foeth and all, well I am glad to see that my Bismarck speed calculation exercise was of interests for you guys. If we concentrate and leverage on everybody skill and knowledge that we can really move things forward :D . I will not comment on the error margin or tolerances th...

Ciao Randy and all, thanks for your explanation of the idioms Randy, ... now at least I got some positive things out of that incident. YES, definitively this reversing '' fashion'' and '' intention to make a scoop '' or to maintain a supposed one is creating too many problems and I can easily unders...

Ciao Randy, George and all, Thanks Randy ! :D YES, I think you got correctly my explanation about the relative or apparent speed ( pardon my not 100 % perfect English therminology knowledge on this ). But in order to get read also from this problem after I measured versus the water column, so that w...

Ciao George and all, Bill work is as usual a very high professional type of analysis were his competences in photogrammetry are fully shown. As he wrote 4 different methods been used. I would like not to anticipate anything as I think once is done everybody will easily realize that. The most difficu...

Ciao Bill and all,

THANKS Bill !!

You are always a very fair guy.

This is the approach everybody must take as cooperating in fairness is the key.

Keep on your good job, and take it easy, I trust you.

Ciao Antonio

Ciao all, to George : as you know the photo reversed theory is the base of Bob theory of Bismarck not turning to starboard for the torpedo alarm issued by Prinz Eugen and continuing straight surpassing the Prinz Eugen to port side at 06.03 and been well ahead of Prinz Eugen at 06.09. This as been de...

Ciao Bob and all, sincerely Bob if I will do here in public what you have asked me I think we will become the most hated people around those forums ( and maybe we are getting close to that right now with this DS battle endless discussion ). I think you have read some last post of people that are sta...

Ciao all,

for reference pourpose only :

http://www.bismarck-class.dk/forum/view ... 2875#12875

Ciao Antonio

Ciao Ian and all, OK, good, I am happy you were able to make up your opinion about all this. I do not know really the reasons of censoring, to me a lot of material was '' managed '' by censors once Prinz Eugen arrived in Brest ( my personal opinion ). I hope that in the close future we will be able ...

Ciao Jose, Bob and all, I do not recall me mentioning any name among the '' several competent guys '' I have referred to. Mr. Winklareth knows well who they are and their opinions. Moving into the '' official version '' showed by the 3 websites I was simply making reference to the Denmark Strait bat...

Ciao iankw and all, sorry I was writing and I did not see your post so my one went out soon after but without considering your statements. Well, I saw you seems to have understood it quite well about the Bismarck turn and Kennedy wordings now, it should be very logic and an easy task. Lets see if Bo...

Ciao Bob and all, come on Bob you must be joking ? Kennedy statements for you are not germane to the issue ? That is exactly the description of the Torpedo alarm by Prinz Eugen at 06.03 and the turn ( by BOTH German ships to comb ) to starboard ( as Prinz Eugen did irrefutably ) while combing the tr...

Ciao iankw and all, newcomers do have a special place in my heart as when I was young and unexperienced about those ships I always dreamed about a possibility to speack with somebody that could have helped me resolving my doubts and my questions, to provide me something to refer to and make up my mi...